Hong Kong Consumer Council recently found that some manufacturers of baby milk formula sold in the island had overstated the nutritional contents of their products.
The Consumer Council said 6 out of 15 types of pre-packaged products reviewed had discrepancies exceeding local food labelling guidelines. The council has sent its findings to the Centre for Food Safety, the agency in charge of enforcing food regulations.
According to Professor Nora Tam Fung-yee, Chairman of the Council’s Research & Testing Committee, giving accurate nutritional information is a basic responsibility of suppliers to their consumers, as such she urges manufacturers to address the concerns promptly.
Wyeth’s Illuma Infant Formula Milk Powder, the most premium brand of milk surveyed, costing HK$539 (US$69.55) for 850g, was found to have 21.9% less amount of vitamin A than what it claimed. The same goes for Meiji Infant Formula which was found to contain 14% less vitamin B3 from its labelling content.
Wyeth explained that the issue was because of different testing methods between the manufacturer and the council. It said the watchdog used a test adopted by the EU, which will yield a result showing less nutrients compared with its tests approved by the International Organisation for Standardisation. Meiji, on the other hand, said its sample complied with international standards set by the Codex Alimentarius Commission, a global food standard agency.
Tam however commented, “The discrepancy in the labelling of the milk formula’s [calories] and 33 nutrients is not that big. It should not affect the nutritional intake of infants.”
The Council’s Chief Executive Gilly Wong said that manufacturers should improve their quality control and review their production process to ensure accurate labelling.
In addition, the Council also found all samples surveyed to be contaminated with 3-MCPD, a substance produced during the refinement of vegetable fat under high heat. If consumed excessively, the contaminant damages kidney functions and the male reproductive system based on laboratory test results. The samples tested were found to have 13 to 120 micrograms per kilogram of 3-MCPD, but they all meet the standards of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (Jecfa), which sets the daily maximum intake of the substance at 17.2mcg/kg.
However, the milk formula with the most 3-MCPD, Organic Infant Formula from Australian brand Bellamy’s Organic, exceeds the limit set by the European Food Safety Authority.
Currently, Hong Kong does not have laws to regulate 3-MCPD produced during food processing, but the Council urges manufacturers to reduce the level of contaminants where possible.
Several infant milk formulas in HK overstate nutritional contents
1.6K