Indonesia and Malaysia, the world’s top two producers of palm oil, have set up a joint task force with the European Union (EU) to address their differences over a new law imposed by the EU on palm oil.
Indonesia and Malaysia have criticized the EU Deforestation-Free Regulation (EUDR), calling it discriminatory and saying its requirements are too strict for producers, particularly small farmers, to comply with.
The palm oil task force is aimed at resolving these issues, and it held its first meeting in Jakarta on 4 August.
Under the EUDR, countries deemed low risk will undergo a simpler due diligence procedure to get their products into the EU, while high-risk countries will have to go through more rigorous checks. The Indonesian government is concerned that if Indonesia is labeled a high-risk country, it will be more difficult to export its palm oil into the EU.
Also discussed during the meeting was the role of sustainability certification schemes, like the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), in the EUDR, to avoid having to draw up new standards for compliance. A spokesperson from Indonesia’s economics ministry said that the Indonesian government will ensure its palm oil exports to the EU to be certified according to EU’s standards. In return, she expected the EU to also recognize certification schemes like the RSPO and Indonesia’s own ISPO in its no-deforestation law. Both are able to trace (palm oil) to plantation level.
The EUDR prohibits imports into the EU of commodities sourced by clearing forests. Palm Oil is one of the targeted commodities apart from soy, timber and even meat products. EUDR also bans commodities coming from illegal sources.
Critics have voiced out that EUDR will affect small farmers as they are unlikely to meet the legal and sustainability criteria set by the EU due to cost and other limitations, effectively locking them out of the global supply chain. And these small farmers’ livelihoods are at stake. Small farmers manage 6.72 million hectares of plantations in Indonesia representing 41% of Indonesia’s palm oil area. This would totally defeat the meaning of ‘sustainability’ from its core.
The joint task force brings together stakeholders who will work together to identify practical solutions in implementing the new regulations.
Both Indonesia and Malaysia had made major strides in reducing deforestation over the past decade. Indonesia reported that its deforestation rate is at its lowest since 1990, down 75% from 2019-2020 period. At the same time, both countries should also look at EUDR as an opportunity to improve the country’s governance of its plantations and agriculture sectors.