The dispute over the ‘Red Bull’ brand in the China market has been going on for more than 2 decades. In 1995, Red Bull Vitamin was authorised to be responsible for the operation and development of the Red Bull brand in China. T.C.Pharmaceutical recognised the authorisation period of the ‘Red Bull’ trademark for 20 years. After the expiration of the authorisation in 2016, T.C.Pharmaceutical authorised the trademark ‘Red Bull’ to Guangzhou Yao Energy Drink Co., Ltd. to launch Red Bull Energy Drink and Red Bull Vitamin Flavoured Drink on the Chinese market.
However, Red Bull Vitamin claimed that the license period for the ‘Red Bull’ trademark is 50 years and that only Red Bull Vitamin has the right to produce and sell Red Bull beverages in China until 2045.
On 21 December 2020, the Supreme People’s Court of China made a final ruling dismissing Red Bull Vitamin’s appeals relating to its claim of ownership of the ‘Red Bull’ series of trademarks. It also confirmed that T.C.Pharmaceutical has independent and complete ownership of the series of ‘Red Bull’ trademarks.
Despite the battle over the ‘Red Bull’ brand, Red Bull Vitamin bucked the trend of the COVID-19 outbreak in 2020 with sales growth in the Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink. According to official data from the company, sales in the beverage industry in China declined year-on-year in the first 3 quarters of 2020 due to COVID-19, with sales of functional beverages falling by approximately 10% over the previous year. However, RedBull Vitamin Functional Drink achieved sales of US$3.53 billion, exceeding its sales target in 2020.
However, Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink’s share of China’s functional drink market decreased to 52% in 2020 from 57% in 2019. It is reported the Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink has relinquished at least US$1.1 billion of its market since the company was caught up in the brand dispute in 2016. That share was filled by other functional drink brands, such as Eastroc Beverage which reported double-digit volume growth of 29%.
In 2021, the market size of functional drinks in China is expected to reach US$21.06 billion. Analysts believe that it is difficult to assess the final result of the Red Bull brand battle in the Chinese market in the short term. As of 7 April, 2021, T.C.Pharmaceutical and its agents have filed a large number of complaints against the distributors of ‘Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink’ to domestic regulators, involving about 646 merchants. As a leading company in the domestic functional beverage market, Red Bull Vitamin not only faces the possibility of losing product sales channels, but also stiff competition from many rivals. All in all, its subsequent development will have an impact on the domestic functional drink market.
Since the beginning of 2021, RedBull Vitamin Functional Drink has been removed from some major domestic online e-commerce platforms, while some convenience stores and supermarkets have also taken the product off their shelves to avoid the legal risks of trademark infringement. uSmile brand of convenience stores, under China National Petroleum Corporation, have also removed RedBull Vitamin Functional Drink from their shelves.
The Chaoyang District People’s Court of Beijing, and the Intermediate People’s Court of Changsha, Hunan Province, have made civil decisions on the act preservation against the lawsuit filed by T.C.Pharmaceutical against the distributors of “RedBull Vitamin Functional Drink”.
On 12 May, Beijing Hualian Hypermarket Co., Ltd. received a ruling to stop selling the infringing goods involved in the case of ‘Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink’ produced by Red Bull Vitamin Drink Co., Ltd., from the immediate date to the date when the final judgment is made and executed.
On 28 May, the Changsha Intermediate People’s Court of Hunan Province issued a ruling that Changsha Huaxia Sugar & Liquor Co., Ltd. (Huaxia Sugar & Liquor) shall stop selling beverage goods containing the Red Bull series of trademarks that are not produced by the legally authorised enterprises of T.C.Pharmaceutical from the immediate date until the date when the final judgment is made and executed. Huaxia Sugar & Liquor is the largest distributor of Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink in Hunan Province, with sales of Red Bull Vitamin Functional Drink exceeding US$36.18 million in 2020.
Red Bull Vitamin said it will do its best to assist Huaxia Sugar & Liquor in filing reconsideration in accordance with the law, and Red Bull China will also defend its rights and interests according to the law.