Italian luxury sportscar manufacturer, Ferrari SpA, renowned worldwide for its prancing horse emblem, has lost a trademark battle to a Malaysian energy drink company.
The High Court in Malaysia dismissed Ferrari’s legal action against Sunrise-Mark Sdn Bhd, ruling that the latter’s ‘Wee Power’ logo cannot be confused with Ferrari’s world-famous mark and that it could proceed to registration. Judge Adlin Abdul Majid made it clear that Ferrari’s claims of potential confusion did not hold water. Ferrari, as the plaintiff, had filed the originating summons against Sunrise-Mark to set aside the Registrar of Trademarks’ decision to dismiss its opposition and allow the latter’s trademark application last year.
Ferrari had argued that Sunrise-Mark’s trademark, featuring 2 rearing horses facing each other with a bold letter W between them and the words ‘Wee Power’ below, infringed on its exclusive rights to the iconic single rearing horse used on its cars, merchandise and global branding.
Ferrari also tried to play down the words ‘Wee Power’ by arguing that the term ‘Power’ was disclaimed in the trademark registration, and that the word ‘Wee’ was too generic to be considered unique. However, the court in its 30 May decision disagreed with the plaintiff on grounds that the only similarity between the marks was the horses. The plaintiff’s mark is a device mark with one rearing horse while the defendant’s (Sunrise-Mark) mark contains 2 rearing horses facing each other. In addition, there is a large letter ‘W’ between the 2 horses and the words ‘Wee Power’ below them.
In addition, the word ‘Wee’ is derived from the name of the defendant’s Founder, Wee Juan Chien, entirely unrelated to Ferrari.
Judge Adlin also said the court found no reasonable likelihood that someone shopping for an energy drink would confuse it with Ferrari’s luxury vehicles. Both are in different industries and do not compete with one another directly.
The court ended the session by ordering the carmaker (Ferrari) to pay the legal costs.